and cite:
Eberhard R. Hilf;
Electronic Services in the Sciences:
international work-sharing, competition,
quality control- and the habits of us all;
given at
Palmer School of Library Science, Long Island University, USA ;
12th Dec. 2002
physnet.uni-oldenburg.de/~hilf/vortraege/nyc02/
The ISN
Institute for Science Networking Oldenburg
Mission:
design and development of services for
the information management for sciences.
What we do: Search services, science portals, metadata, workflow
Our customers:
-
European Physical Society EPS
-
Max Planck Society with its 85 nationwide distributed Institutions
-
National topical Libraries
-
European Nuclear Physics Center GSI
-
..
Collaborators:
Julika Mimkes,
Thomas Severiens
Michael Hohlfeld
Heinrich Stamerjohanns
and 10 students
Industrial revolutions come in a set of related phase transitions
- .. in new undreamt-of possibilities and opportunities
to act
[1994, when the www came up; January 94: web-servers of departments]
-
.. in new unforseen powerful technical tools
[1998: PHP, SQL, java, ..]
-
.. in new unexpected services
[2002: intelligent search, metadata, simulations, interactive modules,..]
-
.. in new unimagined effective research and teaching habits
[just-in-time international cooperation, external quality control of teaching,
and research]
What to learn from Physics about Phase Transitions?
Infinite Systems show
- sudden transitions
- infinitely large fluctuations
- before and after: a homogenous system
- new structures have no
resemblance with the former one
- infinite transition coordinated effort necessary
Finite Systems show
We aim at future stable structures, qualitatively different from what we are used to.
We have a problem of convincing our local colleagues in a world of transition.
global new ways of communication and cooperation
From a time of 'blind trust' in a stable structure
[users know what to expect from a refereed journal article,
librarians know what skills they need, what tasks they have]
moving towards a new future time of 'blind trust', we do not know yet.
We have to define, learn, and implement
Thus in a time of change librarians have to cooperate worldwide and
with their customers to find out what their future skills and tasks are to be.
How to change the habits of us all
Some examples of International Coooperations
1. MareNet, and PhysNet
are sets of link lists.
2. OAD Open Archive Distributed for Physics and Graduates
- NSF-DFG Project Partners: Virginia Technology, SUB Göttingen
- Integrate worldwide heterogenous document sources
Realization by Heinrich Stamerjohanns by
[Import of metadata into a 'Container',
mapping to an internal format, export from container to
an OAi-data provider PhysNet.]
[OAi Open Archive Initiative for free and easy exchange of metadata].
- Heterogeneous distributed archives included are
PhysDoc,
ArXiv, all journals of IoPP,
PhysDiss-International.
- OAD is a registred OAi Data provider
- compliant as OAi Service Provider [ca. 150.000 Documents]
- OAi-Installation-programme in-time for the
release des OAi 2.0 PMH Protocol.
- Retrieval with ranking.
-
robot to find local scientific documents
(Factor 10 to PhysNet),
-
dynamic field-specific vocabular for intelligent
Search engine.
Once the full document is free online available,
then in the ocean of possible add-on services competing
leads to a boost towards more effective and useful services.
Example: Dissonline at CvO:
first: perfect service, no customers by local library.
Once the department set the rules and put up a server,
the library took over.
-
by local colleagues (University Publishers)
- by scientific community (ArXiv)
- by next generation: Redundant living Longterm archiving of
distributed documents
Improvement of Quality and Professionalism
- Lossless publication
full text, mathematic content (MathML),
proofs, codes, data
-
publish first, do refereeing and vetting then
allows multiple serious and adapted vetting
and refereeing levels
[see
peer reviewing of physics publications]
-
Content rewriting
['representation mapping': code, math (components, component-free,
integral, differential, geometry object, experimental setup, ..
for the same content!]
-
condensing to usable material
instead of reading through piles of marginal papers
-
keep information retrievable (long term archiving means
constant lossless mapping of content)
Some Portals and Entry Points to Science Fields
Virtual Physics
is a joint enterprise of the topical National Library in Germany, TIB Hannover.
Partners are
all physics departments, the national libraries and the STN Host.
Concept: vertically structured , well refereed professional collection of
collections.
Example:
ViFaPhys
leads via 'math.Methoden..' and Publications' to e.g. ArXiv
(see Frank Patalong,
Spiegel
journal 2002 ,
- Netted Dynamic Field-specific Thesauri to answer what was expected (and not asked..)
- Connecting query, querier-information and history for personalized retrieval.
eLearning refereed quality filters
Physik Multimedial PMM
is a project of the five North-German Universities.
-
Teaching class
PMM
Platform
-
Search engine LiLi (distributed sources worldwide)
lili
LiLi uses an own
Metadata-set based on [DC, IEEE, LOM, Ariadne]
as proposed by us for the GAP Project [German Academic Publishers]
- technical check for readability
- bibliographic checking (references, metadata, formats, completeness)
- author as scientist at a University
- research group leader approval
- institute approval
- department series inclusion
- blind refereeing
- open annotation refereeing
Longterm archiving in Physics
IUPAP-Conference Lyon 2001:
LTADDP Long term archiving of distributed documents in Physics
Participants:
most international publishers, national libraries and societies.
The one unanomous opinion is being cast into Charters.
A.
IUPAP
(International Union for Pure and Applied Physics),
and
EPS.
This
DRAFT-Paper is open for discussion.
physnet.uni-oldenburg.de"~hilf/eps/eps-ltadp.html
EPS (Acion Committee for Publication and Scientific
Communication ACPaSC) recommendations will be:
- Distributed redundant Archiving:
-
Local material archiving to be organized by
the library of the author's institution.
- Longtime archiving by the National Libraries
- non-proprietary formats only (XML, CML, MAthML, XML, SGML, html, LaTeX,..)
- archiving the full document content
- Ensure nternational Retrieval-Standards (Metadata)
- Support for condensing and reformatin content
- multiple vetting/certification levels
- free access for scientists and students
How to change attitudes of individuals in what is not their profession?
Mismatch of taken risks (traffic vs. lightning)
Prejudices:
I know how I am doing things, I do it so long that way,
therefore I am an expert..
Indeed: humans feel good in structures they are familiar with,
thus they must be good.
I want to get all references for my research;
I do not care about getting read, nor to be visible on the Web.
I am proud of having papers being cited twice
(and I do not know that free full text online papers are cited
up to ten times.)
I want to become hired as professor: so better fullfill the rules
(and assume it is the number of citations, papers, talks, visits,..
.. and do not realize that criteria are changing,- not the
intent to find the best one.)
I write well written sketches of my research findings to impress the
referees
(and never learnt that those who distributed their full code,
opened a more long standing respect and progress.)
I neither know nor care for long term archiving.
But commercial publishers are not interested either
(no way to make money now),
and government is just exploring how to do that,-
and to archive what!
(Marginal papers are not to be archived
[cited from Zinn-Justin, Montonen and others]
What is needed to change the habits of us all are
seldom found and therefore called Leadership qualities.
The future Librarians skills and tasks
- participate in research and development of international standards
and services
-
organize posting of University material
-
train professional retrieval
-
support creation and usage of eLearning modules
-
participate in distributed long term archiving undertaking
-
support free open access of science results (OAi intiative)
Give your remarks
and serve me a wine!